Hey guys, these are the first two sigs i have ever made, i made them just now

i want to know what you think of them, and which one is better (theres not much difference)
dont be afraid to be as mean as you like, but bear in mind that this is my first attempt at sig making.

See? Hardly any difference lol
It did lose a bit of quality however, but their alright
if you can say what you like about it, and what to add/take away, it would be greatly appriciated

And if you want to know, the character is Edward Elric from Full Metal Alchemist
also accepting pm's
EDIT: ah crap forgot to add borders..well i cba right now
