Official Graphics Comments & Criticism

[ssbb_lover]

My latest sigs:

I don't like the 1st, 2nd is great, 3rd is OK.

Here is a sig I made and have played around with. Which looks best?

I'd say #2, because the text matches the render. Nice bg.

[Ads]

[Star Striker]

Thanks Ty.

Anyone else like to give C and C? Any advice I get really helps and I think that since I've started posting my work here it has gradually became better.

[Spaggy]

Cool bg on the last ones. I have to say #2 here as well, because #3 has a bit too much lighting, I think. Cool details though, with the face and the cross and all.

The first I don't like that much, and the render looks like the opacity has been lowered or something. The second one is really cool, but the black seems to be taking over from the left. That, and I can't really see the text. Great bg though. It's probably just my monitor, but I couldn't see the text o the third at first. I moved it a bit and now it shows clearly. Good job

[Star Striker]

Maybe my monitor is a bit brighter and I thought it looked alright when I was making it. It's happened before.



With all these 'OTW competitions what would you guys and gals think of a Render Of The Month competition?

[Wii_Smurf]

Hmm I dunno

Anyways I just made this.
Not added the text yet or the border. Just the basic sig

What ya think?

[Star Striker]

Play around with a few adjustment layers on the render as it isn't as colourful as the bg - e.g. saturation, contrast etc


Also try and recreate the lighting on the render onto the bg.

[Wii_Smurf]

First time using the Pen tool, I made this.
I added it to the signature but I don't think it makes it any better. Your thoughts?

[Byuakuya]

Here is a sig I made and have played around with. Which looks best?

I personally like the first one. I have to agree, the BG is very good and the text is also very nice.

[King Wiired]

First time using the Pen tool, I made this.
I added it to the signature but I don't think it makes it any better. Your thoughts?

It doesn't, no, I'm afraid. It's just random, the pen tools gotta be used with a flow to be used sufficiently

[Wii_Smurf]

Lol
Does the Signature without the scribble look any good?