Just like how I think Castle Siege is not bad.
I hate both. And also the character Yoshi but that may just be a bias.
You shut your Tragomouth. Brawl Yoshi's Island is a great stage; and it's a neutral.
also i chose halberd via random lawl <3 dat staeg
I like most of the stages in Brawl. I dislike 75 m and Flat Zone 2 the most. I would say Mario Bros, but that stage doesn't even try to be remotely serious, so I'm cool with it. There are some other stages that I don't like, but they're low in number.
Also, I like how there are always two that share an opinion and one that disagrees with that opinion for a stage.
Fountain of Dreams: 1 Like (MR) ; 2 Dislikes ('Karp, Trago)
Castle Siege: 2 Likes ('Karp, Trago) ; 1 Dislike (MR)
Yoshi's Island (Melee): 1 Like (MR) ; 2 Dislikes ('Karp, Trago)
Yoshi's Island (Brawl): 2 Likes ('Karp, MR) ; 1 Dislike (Trago)
Lylat Cruise: 2 Likes ('Karp, Trago) ; 1 Dislike (MR)
Skyworld: 2 Likes ('Karp, Trago) ; 1 Dislike (MR)
I find it funny how MR likes all of the stages I don't like, and vice versa. 'Karp is just the tiebreaker.