None of the game of year awards are actualy official! The show spike tv had said bioshock won, i fell asleep on the one G4Tv had, i know other websites have gave it to bioshock as well as Galaxy. It is all a matter of your opinion because what might be great to some one might not to you. But i would say its between Galaxy, MassEffect, and from the demo i played of Bioshock it was up there too. Assasins creed could have been up there too but the gameplay got repetitive. God of war 2 could be thrown in the mix too, as well as Ratchet and Clank.