Master Jedi asked me for this, so here it goes:
All I can say is, wow. The game to me seemed so awesome at first, great storyline, long hours of playing, responsive controls. However, I rented the Two Thrones at the same time. Basically, its the exact same thing. The exact same thing. While the Wii specific controls are fun, you will rarely use them. Basically, this is Ubisoft's attempt to make some extra money on The Two Thrones by throwing in some poorly done extra controls. If you've never played the Two Thrones, this is a must buy, if you have, stay away from this.
n00bs to PoP: 9/10
PoP fans (or have played the Two Thrones): 6/10