Haha, sorry but you know so far RE4 hasnt been TO incredibly scary.
(btw, i didnt ever get very far in the gamecube version)
But now that I am INSIDE that castle in chapter 3. Well it was a bit eerie getting there with all the voices. And then I go into a prison chamber. And the devil is there with HUGE claws! HE DESTROYED ME.
And now I take a breather because anytime i get killed in a game i want to turn it off...