When I got the Wii, I wanted every game out there but wound up with a few duds just because I was excited and overenthusiastic about buying. So, I signed up for a Gamefly.com membership (kinda like Netflix) because I live in the middle of nowhere and am not good at returning things on time. So far I'm pretty happy with it. Monthly membership is a little pricey, but the selection and service has been good, and I like their "rent-to-own" options where you can keep the game you're renting if you want.
Just curious where the rest of you rent from, if you do? How do you like it? Which places have good selections and prices?