SensesFail: But it would suck to leave out Zelda because it was released late.
And yea, Halo better not win.
And no, I like Mario Galaxy, but its way to casual for me. There was nothing challenging about that game whatsoever. It was new and innovative compared to older Marios but no where near as challenging as older ones like Super Mario World, which is the best Mario ever made :P I'll get that on VC one day.