Bioshock was great. Mario was great, but lacked any challenge to make it GOTY. Rockband is really good if u like really like Rock Music, though I personally don't but there's no denying how fun it can be for a fan so I dont doubt its position. Mass Effect should be higher I think, though it did have some bugs, it wasnt so bad to get lower than alot of those games. I think GOTY should have been The Orange Box, Bioshock or Call of Duty 4.