I dont agree with that replay games there. I dont play them anymore because its the same over and over.
Every now and than when Im bored ill put in wiisports or for that matter mario kart double dash when I had the gamecube and It can occupy me for half an hour. And than it goes away for a week or 2
Replay value to me ( and I also think to the officials ) stands for playing a game different when you play it the second time.
This would be: Being on the enemy's side in a fps shooter, playing with different units in an rts or being a completely different class and allignment ( evil instead of good ) in an RPG