No, we would hit the home button on the first remote and then go to remote settings, then reconnect. Then you hit the 1-2 button on each remote. I thought I had sync'd it once, but it turned out I must not have. After trying the snyc thing again, it works as it should.
There's a black flat style Classic Controller circulating Ebay that has the Wii markings, but is clearly a knock-off (the box says "Shiro" which is white, instead of Kuro which is black, so that's an obvious tip off right there). And now there are even knock-offs of the Classic Controller Pro cluttering up Ebay. If it's ''amazingly cheap'' chances are it's a bootleg. You're better off just going to your local Best Buy, Wal-Mart, Game Stop or whatever, atleast then you're not wasting your money on a bootleg, and if it doesn't work correctly you can always exchange it or get a refund.