LoginRegister
Nintendo Wii / Wii U Forum
+ Reply to Thread
Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 10 of 14
Like Tree2Likes

Thread: What do you think of the first gen?

  1. #1
    WiiChat Member lucktown's Avatar
    Member #
    91803
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Munich, Germany
    Posts
    310
    Friends
    3
    Wii Friend Code: $post[field5]
    0000-0000-0000-0000

    What do you think of the first gen?

    How good do you think is it compared to the other gens? Why do you like/not like it?
    I haven't seen anything like this here (tell me if there is) and there are a lot of people thinking that it still is the best one (not talking about the people who say every other gen sucks). I am interested in what you think.


    I really like it, but in my opinion it is in the bottom half of the Pokemon games. It is a great start for the series, but some things in the game are broken (for example the crit ratio) and you don't have that many Pokemon to choose from. The Pokemon designs are as good as in every other Pokemon game and even though it's not my favorite now, it still is by far my favorite childhood game (played it since I was 4 and still sometimes play it).
    Last edited by lucktown; 05-31-2013 at 02:22 PM.

  2. #2
    Protein! WiiAssasin's Avatar
    Member #
    65950
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Location
    Mira
    Posts
    6,274
    Friends
    19
    Wii Friend Code: $post[field5]
    7912-1706-4691-2520
    inb4mr
    3DS FC: 1478-4144-3572


    Trying to motivate myself to play: F.E.A.R., Skyrem.
    Spoiler Alert!

  3. #3
    #MilkshakeSwag Koshi's Avatar
    Member #
    90390
    Join Date
    Oct 2012
    Location
    Bidoof World
    Posts
    128
    Friends
    52
    Wii Friend Code: $post[field5]
    0400-3955-5470-3010
    1st Gen? Ahhhhhhhh, the nostalgia... Defeating trainers one by one with Cha-Squirtle

    All in all, it's a great Gen. I'm suprised no one really abandoned Red, Blue and Yellow (Not much Green), Even though I know that they're the games that started it all.

  4. #4
    WiiChat Member lucktown's Avatar
    Member #
    91803
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Munich, Germany
    Posts
    310
    Friends
    3
    Wii Friend Code: $post[field5]
    0000-0000-0000-0000
    Quote Originally Posted by WiiAssasin View Post
    inb4mr
    That probably sounds dump, but what do you mean by that?


    Quote Originally Posted by Koshi View Post
    Defeating trainers one by one with Cha-Squirtle
    Squirtle ftw (although Bulbasaur is pretty awesome too)

    Quote Originally Posted by Koshi View Post
    I'm suprised no one really abandoned Red, Blue and Yellow
    I think it will never die. It's very popular for the age, sequels, and good remakes.

  5. #5
    WiiChat Member lildan596's Avatar
    Member #
    91655
    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Location
    United States
    Posts
    51
    Friends
    4
    Wii Friend Code: $post[field5]
    1sr gen fav gen
    SSBB code 0476 4746 5983 pm me if you want to play i also have project m

  6. #6
    WiiChat Member lucktown's Avatar
    Member #
    91803
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Munich, Germany
    Posts
    310
    Friends
    3
    Wii Friend Code: $post[field5]
    0000-0000-0000-0000
    Quote Originally Posted by lildan596 View Post
    1sr gen fav gen
    I wanted to know why. I know that many people prefer the first gen, but I want to hear different reasons than "all other gens suck"

  7. #7
    The Scrubbiest of Hunters Splash_King's Avatar
    WiiChat Moderator
    Member #
    55490
    Join Date
    Jan 2009
    Location
    Lostlorn Forest
    Posts
    16,246
    Friends
    123
    Wii Friend Code: $post[field5]
    0129-0129-0129-0129
    Quote Originally Posted by WiiAssasin View Post
    inb4genwunmystyrsnessnesses
    fix'd

    Quote Originally Posted by lucktown View Post
    How good do you think is it compared to the other gens?
    Comparing Gen 1 t' newer Generations without respecting the retro games' time periods, obviously every game which came after RBY is better. Better balance, moar Pokemon, better overworlds and more battle complexity. This much is obvious. As such, it's a very pointless comparison.

    'Course, comparin' the games when keepin' in mind their date of release and what they did for the series is actually a valid topic of discussion. In that regard, I'd say RBY is very high up there. Obviously it's the start'a things and for it's time, was ****in' brilliant. Pokemon's formula as a game was excellent and original. RG took the staple turn based RPG formula and renovated it with innovative ideas such as the necessity of trading. Never before had an RPG embraced such a social aspect like trading 'n battling with friends in such an interestin' way. I wouldn't be surprised if there's some tacked-on multiplayer for a retro RPG, but Pokemon was designed with such a thing in mind. T'is why version differences were spawned, to further build upon the need to trade by makin' certain 'mons exclusive to a particular version.

    I could go on further 'bout why RG were such grand games, but that's not necessarily the topic. My point is that RBY could certainly be considered the height of the series 'cause of what it brought t' handheld gaming, as well as settin' the grand series into motion.

    GSC did some nice things for the series; 'specially Pokemon designs IMO; but wasn't exactly revolutionary like RG was. RSE was even less innovative indeed, bringin' only extra battle complexity to the series via abilities, the Battle Frontier and Double Battles. DPP really delved into Pokelore, literally the most important addition t' battle complexity with the physical-special split and the introduction of GTS and Wi-Fi play. The latter-most option is without a doubt the most important thing for Pokemon as a series, since multiplayer; one'a Pokemon's defining features; could now be conducted between people at any time across any distance... however, this wasn't an innovation so much as an expected feature. Ain't like t'was the first DS game t' implement Wi-Fi. As such, DPP can't really take credit for that sadly.

    Finally, we have BW1/2. I believe Gen 5 is the only Generation that can compete with what RG did for the series. BW1 brought an actual focus on story for the first time in forever. Actual character development and a focus on the logic behind a character's personality and their role in the story. A truly grand game can't just be raw great gameplay. This step forward for the series is an incredibly important one indeed, for the betterment of Pokemon as a whole. Too much weight can't be put on this since it ain't like BW1's plot is the work of an author with immaculate writin' skill or nothin', but I'm moreso concerned by the fact BW1 might of been a huge turning-point for the series to begin includin' some real stories inside the tried 'n true formula of Pokegameplay.

    Unlike DPP, BW1/2 did innovate with Wi-Fi like few non-PC games have done before; if any at all; with the Dream World. GTS connected the world's trainers, now the Dream World gave these trainers somethin' more than trading and battling. Somethin' completely different.

    Another good point would be the music. I haven't wholly enjoyed Pokesoundtracks like I did RBY and GSC's 'til Gen 5 rolled on in. An NPC in Gen 5 actually mentions how Game Freak worked extra hard on the tunes, and I really felt like that effort shined through. Nostalgia aside, I believe Gen 5 actually has the best PokeOSTs to date. I feel Game Freak really gave it their all for BW1.

    Lastly, BW2 itself. BW2 has officially broken the mold of the Yellow/Crystal/Emerald of every Generation. No more cleaned up re-releases sold at full price. Instead'a minor fixes to the plot, we now get a true sequel with a new plot all together. I think we can all agree that this is a welcome change, and a huge one at that.

    With my thoughts on the matter spoken, I'd honestly say that if you take away the fact Gen 1 was the beginnin' of the series and therefore automatically gets the win for innovation, Gen 5 takes the cake. This Generation brought some non-battle complexity improvements 'n innovation to the series not yet seen outside of grand ol' spin-offs like Mystery Dungeon. Furthermore, as mentioned 'bout the plot, the window is open for Gen 6 to REALLY steal the spotlight. The true venture into 3D Pokegames Colosseum 'n XD failed to implement, the possibility of the games havin' a grandeur plot... BW1/2 was the beginning of a new beginning for Pokemon, I'd say.

    Gen 5 > Gen 1
    Last edited by Splash_King; 05-31-2013 at 10:02 PM.
    lucktown and BuzzWord like this.

    The Vermilion City Guru
    絶望の海。水の墓。スプラッシュ、コイキング!

    Spoiler Alert!

  8. #8
    Love, Peace, and Comfort! The_Man's Avatar
    Member #
    84488
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    Dangan Ronpa Academy
    Posts
    722
    Friends
    57
    Wii Friend Code: $post[field5]
    1234-1234-1234-1234
    Personally, If feel that gen 1 was the starting point of a franchise, by no means is it bad but the other ones improved the concept, while still keeping the parts you love. Still, I think Gen 5 takes the cake as the best.

    Brawl 2192 8924 8771

    Goldeneye 368263462467


    Spoiler Alert!

  9. #9
    WiiChat Member Espmaster_'s Avatar
    Member #
    60582
    Join Date
    Jun 2009
    Posts
    363
    Friends
    26
    Wii Friend Code: $post[field5]
    7463-2792-2066-1973
    Gen 1 was a very flawed generation. Much of the praise for it goes to its concept, and its concept certainly was a great one. However, the developers took alot of easy ways out when designing the game, mostly because of it being rushed to the market. This leads to weird gameplay mechanics (such as the critical/speed relationship and boxes needing to be manually changed) as well as a plethora of strange glitches. Concepts aside, Gen 1 pales in comparison to another other generation, because the Pokemon available and the moves of those Pokemon didn't open the doors to a huge amount of strategy. However, is it really fair to judge it in retrospect? First time playing through the game, it is definately an enjoyable and fulfilling experience. With newer games out, there are three reasons one might want to go back and play the old ones.
    1. The difference in the way the game works. Pokemon that are now considered useless, like Flareon, were excellent then because of the completely different stat system and balance in the games.
    2. Nostalgia. I guess you can argue that we have FR/LG for that, but some people may feel it's not quite the same.
    3. Glitches. Alot of fun to mess around with. Some of the glitches in this are among the most famous in video game history, namely Missingno and the Mew Glitch.

    Whenever I hear this game described, I hear extremely cliche phrases like "had to start somewhere" and "good beginning to the series." And while this is very true, I want to explain this position in more detail.
    Like I said, this game is nothing to other games in the series, with all of its numerous programming flaws and one-sided battle mechanics. However, if you compare it, not to other Pokemon games, but to RPGs as a whole, you notice that these games bring the RPG concept to a whole new level with the inclusion of over 100 catchable team mates, rather than a select few you get by doing side quests. This makes the games more fun in several ways: for one, you have something worthwhile to collect. For another, you can choose whatever you want, mix and match, get it whenever you want, teach it whatever you want; in other words, your entire team is up to you. It's really no wonder that these games quickly because the coolest thing to do in elementary schools everywhere, and is still going strong today.
    Last edited by Espmaster_; 06-03-2013 at 08:43 PM.
    Avatar drawn by Redreavus.
    Attachment 11127Attachment 11126

  10. #10
    WiiChat Member lucktown's Avatar
    Member #
    91803
    Join Date
    Apr 2013
    Location
    Munich, Germany
    Posts
    310
    Friends
    3
    Wii Friend Code: $post[field5]
    0000-0000-0000-0000
    So most people agree that it is good, because it is the start of the series and added new things to the series (Splash_King was very accurate with that ) and because of the big nostalgia factor, but it still looses to all or most other generations.

Ads

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts