otacon138
wiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
The Gamespot review is in...
Just go to GameSpot
restitial, the review is linked on the homepage... :'(
Just go to GameSpot
restitial, the review is linked on the homepage... :'(Awful Gamespot review
- Thread starter otacon138
- Start date
sweeney
WiiChat Member
i know ,this really sucks. i was expecting red steel to be a good, fun game that would be a great way to use the wii to its limits. now all im getting at launch is zelda
MetroidZ
Only took 4 years to get1
Look at zelda, 8.8? the average is about 9.8. gamespot has lost all respect from me. And I don't care about red steel, to me it looks awesome, I'm getting it.
sweeney
WiiChat Member
come on................ it wouldn't be getting bad reviews if it was a great game. I understand why people are ignoring gamespots review because of the "8.8" it gave zelda. But this was because they considered it a next gen game and it is really a port from gamecube to wii. and they do give some pretty stupid reviews. But red steel wouldn't be getting "5.5" if it wasnt a bad game. i may still get it solely because i want to try it out. But i will probaly trade it in shortly after towards perhaps monkey ball
tuned
11.19.06
It's still just someone else' opinion. Who cares really? Zelda is pretty high on my 'must have' list, and RedSteel is the first game I'm planning on picking up, regardless.
MetroidZ
Only took 4 years to get1
IGN ftw! :yesnod:
- Thread Starter
- Thread starter
- #10
im a member of gamespot (genji_glove1 to any1 wanting 2 be friends) and i personally dont really like Jeff Gershman, the guy who did the TP review. I trust the opinion of Greg Kasavin though, another editor. Maybe i'll wait to see what he says.
hey
Well I haven't seen, nor know of any of the GameSpot reviews, so I dunno.
@sweeney: Hmm, and you think other places that reviewed Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess didn't also take those things into account? and yet I think they still gave it a great score.
---
Ohh, and while we are talking about such things... I have some things to say about IGN. Sorry if I'm over reacting, but I get the feeling that some at IGN maybe putting their personal views in front of what something really is, if that makes any sense?
I was quite shocked to see they rated the Sound in Zelda only 8.0, just because it wasn't orchestrated, I think that's a bit hard. I actually really like MIDI/Mod music, and I think it's more of a personal thing, but I dunno. I think the most important thing is the composition of the music, and the atmosphere and emotion it brings ^_^. I also thought that the hit to Rayman Raving Rabbids may have been a tad hard also, although I can better understand about the push of support for progressive scan in games.
Finally, I very much don't agree about their comments on the lack of voice acting in Zelda. I think for such a thing it's better to just use your imagination, as I imagine everyone has a different image of Link's, and others voices. I do enjoy to use my imagination, must everything be defined? Hehe. Hmm, makes me think they would prefer movies, rather than books .
cyas
Well I haven't seen, nor know of any of the GameSpot reviews, so I dunno.
@sweeney: Hmm, and you think other places that reviewed Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess didn't also take those things into account? and yet I think they still gave it a great score.
---
Ohh, and while we are talking about such things... I have some things to say about IGN. Sorry if I'm over reacting, but I get the feeling that some at IGN maybe putting their personal views in front of what something really is, if that makes any sense?
I was quite shocked to see they rated the Sound in Zelda only 8.0, just because it wasn't orchestrated, I think that's a bit hard. I actually really like MIDI/Mod music, and I think it's more of a personal thing, but I dunno. I think the most important thing is the composition of the music
, and the atmosphere and emotion it brings ^_^. I also thought that the hit to Rayman Raving Rabbids may have been a tad hard also, although I can better understand about the push of support for progressive scan in games.Finally, I very much don't agree about their comments on the lack of voice acting in Zelda. I think for such a thing it's better to just use your imagination, as I imagine everyone has a different image of Link's, and others voices. I do enjoy to use my imagination
, must everything be defined? Hehe. Hmm, makes me think they would prefer movies, rather than books .cyas
Last edited:
Demon Slayer
Jay
Right now Gamespot is nothing to me..i mean after looking at them playing the wii. i then realize that they know nothing in gaming...if you want reviews go on IGN. they're the only reliable game site online
MetroidZ
Only took 4 years to get1
me too, I go on gamespot a lot (I'm OGTiago) and when I saw jeff play with the Wii, you just knew he was never interested with the Wii. There is something wrong with him.otacon138 said:
Heres a petition I saw (on gamespot) If your unhappy with the review, just sign the petition: Legend Of Zelda: The Twilight Princess Gamespot Review Petition
mrserv0n248
WiiChat Member
- Nov 14, 2006
- 65
- 0
OMG! 5.5 on RED STEEL!
Gamespot which is easily one of the most reputable sites out there, And generally stern and fair threw Red Steel a 5.5!!!! I am SOOO MAD :mad2:
Red Steel for Wii Review - Wii Red Steel Review
Gamespot which is easily one of the most reputable sites out there, And generally stern and fair threw Red Steel a 5.5!!!! I am SOOO MAD :mad2:
Red Steel for Wii Review - Wii Red Steel Review
