Yeah, I got to level 9 too. And my voting eye is "inexperienced" or something like that (my wii is in spanish). I improved my mario mii before the results (but couldn't send it) and it looked very similar to the first 50, though.
to explain there are two different things going on here your judging eye and your mii creation level.... the level you are is what the mii you created reached in my case it was a lvl 9 but my judge eye was above average.
so two different things going on at same time... i got to do a photo for doing so well wiht a lvl9 what rewards did some of the other lvl's get?