Super Mario Galaxy >>>> #1 game of all time???

[diaoman]

Currently, SMG has a 96.2% rating on gamerankings.com . If gets even more high ratings from the other publications (especially the nintendo-hating Gamespot), it could surpass Ocarina of Time (97.6%) and become the greatest game of all time! Let's hope so....

 

[wiifreak9292]

i think its a little too early to call it the best game of all time...

 

[Sillyhat]

That's a big mountain to climb.

 

[Spyro]

Ssbb > Smg

 

[ssbb_lover]

SSBB > SMG, for sure. But, by the way everyone is talking, SMG sounds incredible.

 

[phillepino]

SMG dont look that appealing to me

 

[Budo]

The title of best game of all time has already been given to Half-Life 2. :lol:

 

[Byuakuya]

I am sure that SMG will be an excellent game, but will be the best game of all time? Only time itself can tell.

 

[CyanRussel]

I Believe That It Will Be

The Greatest Game Of All Time

 

[samXcor3]

i think its a little too early to call it the best game of all time...

especially considering time is like...infinite.

 

[Ronald]

World of Warcraft ftw, Rofl.

 

[CyanRussel]

The LOZ...installment to Wii or Wii 2

 

[manufan15]

I've got to play this if they're rating close to the top of all time!! Can't wait!!

 

[stok3d]

SSBB > SMG, for sure. But, by the way everyone is talking, SMG sounds incredible.

It's interesting how people say Brawl is better than Galaxy, especially when Brawl isn't even out yet and is from a totally different genre.

'Greatest Game of All-Time' is far too broad a statement to be taken very seriously since we all have different ideas on what a truly great game is.

Don't get me wrong, Galaxy is a triumph, a marvel, but again, to call it the best of all time is both premature and genre-dependent.

 

[CantGetAWii]

It looks great no doubt.
But greatest game of all time is quite the stretch.