For me, they're: 1) Shawshank Redemption, which was boring as hell, but is somehow imdb.com's number one. 2) The Godfather, because it completely and utterly failed to keep my attention for one hour, let alone 3. (This is coming from a guy who watched Magnolia on a regular basis.) 3) Crash 2004. Jesus, that movie wants to be Magnolia and Short Cuts so bad. It screams "I'm anti-racism, so you have to love me!" In opinion, it's the worst film to ever win best picture. What the **** were they thinking? So, what are yours? I'm talking most overrated as in movies that the critics really loved, as opposed to movies that sucked but were really popular. If we get into the latter, we basically have all mainstream horror films in the past 7 years and all the shitty teen comedies. Of course, there are definitely more... So, what movies do you think are overrated by either the critics or the general public?